
Recently I’m hearing and reading arguments against “going green”. But when I really listen and think about what’s being said, these arguments are as shallow and unthinking as the term “green”. In my mind this is all bumper sticker politics intended to serve up simple one dimensional arguments, for or against, without speaking the complete truth or supporting critical thought. My case for sustainable foods and systems will require participation, thought, and even some sacrifice. These are dangerous arguments to make in a “I work hard for what I have”, do my own thing, “freedom” loving America. So allow me to start here: I politely ask everyone to consider that they’re also “free” to choose a better system for themselves. I urge each of you to look at how hard you work to provide foods that aren’t nutritious, often dangerous, and wasteful to yourself and your family. Think about needing less money and less hours at work, instead develop new resources so you can enjoy more. Lastly, know that your free to use any product or system available, but you can make choices that are cheaper, sustainable, high quality, and healthier. You simply don’t need to view sustainability as limits or take aways, it’s choice.

I recently read an article that stated that buying organic hot house tomatoes in New England in the dead of Winter uses more energy than shipping tomatoes from Southern Mexico by truck and rail to the same New England town. Though I haven’t done the energy calculation myself, allow me to concede that argument. But this was offered as a reason not to source and shop locally. In a sneaky round about way it was a reason to reject sustainability and continue with business as usual. It made the case that “organics” raised prices of food and hurt the poor, it claimed the system is inefficient and couldn’t replace our food supply. It was rejecting sustainability based on one product swop in a temperate zone during Winter, tomato for tomato. Rejecting a sustainable model on those points….. I strongly disagree!
The fact is this is an example of the “sacrifice” I mentioned earlier. No one in New England should be buying Hot House Tomatoes in February, they should be using the jarred tomatoes they put up from their garden last Summer. But people act as if they couldn’t eat if they can’t eat those waxed in petroleum paraffin, shipped thousands of miles and stocked in the local grocery tomatoes or if they can’t get their “grown with loving care” hot house tomatoes that used huge amounts of energy to produce. They speak as if there’s no choice but bad, worst, or starvation. I would argue, not only can you eat, but you can eat well in a New England February using a sustainable model. In that February snow covered New England town there’s abundance! Preserved vegetables, pickles, jams & jellies, honey, beans, polenta, oats, tree nuts, & dried fruits. There’s hundreds of artisan cheeses in the area, beef, poultry, and game. Perch being ice fished from thousands of lakes and ponds, fresh bread and local eggs. With all this, keep a couple things in mind, February is the month with the least sustainable options in New England and we’ve still not looked in a freezer to find the broccoli, cauliflower, and pumpkin that could’ve been frozen from the fall or that in this climate you can have a root cellar with potato, onions, beets, parsnips and garlic. Did I mention Beer? Is this a region on the verge of starvation and having a lack of resources or have we selected and maintained the wrong system?
But we also hear we can’t feed the Earth’s population without large industrial farming in distant places. This I fear is only partly true, it’s not an argument against sustainable methods or organic farms. It’s an argument to put a band aid on for a few years. The truth is more like this, as the world consumes and eats the way we do in the U.S., no system that exists, except starvation, slavery, and death, can take care of the planets population much less our future population. But if we used our resources to produce a little food in our homes and community, we stop consuming unneeded amounts of meat based protein and we reduce the waste in our consumption and production methods, we can feed the world from local sources. I’m not saying we need to be Vegans and eat “tofu” all day. In fact the production of tofu is it’s self a wasteful process. What I’m saying is we can eat the meat we need and feed the world. I’m saying there are systems we can use to produce livestock more humanely and sustainably as long as we’re not consuming hundreds of times more than we need. We don’t need to fish every fish from the oceans, but we do need more plants on our plates and we need to eat a few eggs before we make chicken vegetable soup with that chicken. We need a bowl of steel cut oats and not a grand slam breakfast.
I don’t think I can make the ironclad scientifically supported case for a globally sustainable food system in 2000 words or less, I wouldn’t try. I only seek to create some critical thought and point out we could all be eating locally and in season rather than sourcing from thousands of miles away. We all need to pay attention to the sources of the foods we eat. We can’t just step into Costco, Whole Foods, or our local natural foods co-op and fill our carts with tomatoes in February. I fear “green” is the new “yuppy” movement, with people buying designer recycle bins, trading in their 3 year old SUV for a Prius and buying out the Whole Foods market of products from far flung places without any consideration of what it took to make and ship those products. I think we need to sacrifice a little and think much more. Rather than buying those designer recycle bins with the fancy logo and color coding, just use a humble box from your local market, that’s recycling! More importantly, buy and make less trash, then compost what you can. If you checked, you’d find running your old car until it won’t run any longer is far “greener” than buying any new car. Then when your vehicle finally can’t go any farther, buy the most sustainable vehicle that meets your needs. As for Whole Foods shopping sprees, plant a garden instead. A window box, a 3′x5′ plot on a roof or in a yard. Use everything your garden yields, eat fresh, then dry, can, preserve, and pickle everything else. Barter and trade or just share your abundance rather than throwing away. So feel free to grab one sentence or limited thought and argue against. But I think that’s a plan for sustainability, less BS and a little more common sense.
We need to stop trying to replace apples with apples. People seem to want to trade the brand name disposable razors for “recycled plastic” disposable razors. They want to replace Costco with Whole Foods, but this is replacing one wasteful consumer based system with another wasteful consumer based system. Instead buy an old school straight razor that lasts a lifetime, just stop buying tomatoes when their not growing in your region, and reduce what you buy at any market and plant that garden. I can accept not everyone can do all the things I’m suggesting, hell I’ve not done all the things I’m suggesting. But I am thinking and working towards it every day. I’ve started with things I can do now, I stopped buying bottled water and have a re-usable container. In the Hawaii Sun, and near the sea, I produce salt. A small thing but maybe I can give some away and share my abundance. I’ve started buying everything I can within 75 miles of my home; fruits, vegetables, fish, and even tea. We have a solar hot water heater instead of burning fuels and electricity. I’ve vowed to change my “car trade in history” for better utilization and maintenance instead. Why have I owned 7 cars in the last 27 years? Surely the life of a car is more than 3.85 years! We’ve started a Chef’s garden at work, we’re working hard to buy more locally grown/produced products, and we’re making better choices on menus.
So those are the types of things I’m advocating. Just think more and use less, make changes and not replacements. These changes may be different from person to person and place to place, just get started. Don’t buy into being “yuppy green”, try not to “buy” into anything. Opt for something new instead and make choices that’ll impact you, your family, community, and the world. Eat better, make less trash, use the things you have fully and recycle things when you can’t use them any longer. Do this at home, work, and in the community, then look for a bigger change like getting all the food you need from your land and hard work, great! Go to a solar hot water system rather than burning fuels, excellent. But don’t let this be an argument that says you have less choice, but an argument that your free to choose a smarter system. Think, read, listen, and question…. then act.